John Butler’s address at Global Citizen, on Whadjuk Noongar Boodja (Boorloo/Perth).
John’s address was preceded by former Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and followed by WA Premier Roger Cook. Both presented AI as part of the energy transition, and both set the push for a just transition alongside data centres and the indiscriminate mining of critical minerals (presumably including those mined for warfare). In doing so, they lumped efforts to address global warming in with undertakings that run directly counter to it.
John spoke directly to the dissonance in those speeches: WA’s leaders sing about a green transition while the state expands gas and bauxite mining underneath. He was the only speaker to receive a standing ovation, and it was well deserved.
We thank John Butler for allowing us to publish his speech here, Sophie McNeill for sharing her front row footage with us and Jess Beckerling for liaising with John for the transcript.
I’m John Butler. I’m a songwriter. I’m not a politician, a scientist or a researcher. I’m a musician who writes songs.
I’ve spent most of my life looking for harmony, and working out how to make it happen: how to bring melody, rhythm, chords and words together and find the place where they are all congruent. Each element has to feel just right in relation to the others. When all the parts of a song work together and I discover the right recipe for that particular song, it’s one of the most satisfying things I know, and I’m constantly chasing it.
But before I go any further, I first need to harmonise and tune in with this place.
I’d like to acknowledge the traditional custodians of this country, this Whadjuk Boodja we all have the privilege to be on today. To all the old ones who’ve looked after this country, and all the elders now keeping the fires burning: you have my respect. We are the sum of all our ancestors’ actions, and it’s largely because of their efforts that we are here on this boodja, so I’d also like to pay my respects to your ancestors.
Where I come from
In 1997 I had just left Curtin University to become a full-time busker. Solid career choice: leaving tertiary education to play guitar next to a rubbish bin, asking for change.
Still asking for change.
DIY, grassroots street art and culture became my life. As a result, I witnessed waves of non-violent direct action (NVDA) activists coming up to Fremantle from the blockades down south. They’d come up to organise, fundraise, restock and debrief from the intensity of frontline campaigning.
I was awestruck by what looked like a rag-tag group of ferals who were actually super organised, devoted and focused, and who were putting life and limb on the line to protect our old-growth forests from being clearfelled, bulldozed, woodchipped and sold overseas for less than a dollar a tonne. I felt that what they were doing was of the utmost importance, and truly one of the highest forms of civil service. Protecting country and community from predatory corporations with no interest in our collective futures seemed like the only thing that really mattered.
Jess Beckerling, now a Greens Member of the Legislative Council in WA, was on that bike around the time I first met her.
Then came a Sunday Times front page, “Loggerheads”. It was the equivalent of “Uncle Sam wants you!” It was my enrolment and enlistment moment.
The first blockade I ever went to had a dragon. That car isn’t bogged or parked: it’s dug into the ground on a road. Inside are two 44-gallon drums filled with cement, with locks set in the core so that activists can lock on.
These were the people on the frontline, buying us time. When the courtrooms fail, when corporate policy fails, when government legislation fails, it falls to people like this: bright young minds and souls ready to stop state-funded, police-escorted bulldozers from clearfelling areas of forest that, by the next election, were protected. They bought us time while the rest of the choir made noise in the city, on the streets and in the halls of power, building momentum on campaigns that could tip the result of elections and future legislation.
I was profoundly inspired. The injustice was so evident and the action required so urgent, and I wanted to get involved. And yet I still wanted to make music, and genuinely felt that was where I could have the most impact and wield the most influence. To justify the time I was obsessively spending on my music, I made a conscious decision: if I ever had any success, I’d redirect some of the spotlight towards things more important than my own career.
The song WA is writing
As someone with great respect for the technology and intelligence of nature, I’ve observed that all systems are connected, just like the elements of a song. Ecosystems, political systems, economic systems and social systems all affect each other. You can’t think about one to the exclusion of the others, especially if you want the song to work. Without harmony, we are in a state of dissonance.
So for me, harmony is a lexicon through which I view and understand how systems relate. Having spent most of my life trying to hone it, I’m hyper-sensitive to dissonance as a side effect, whether it’s musical, social, political, environmental or economic. It’s a sensitivity I sometimes wish I didn’t have.
But here we are in WA, ground zero for the dissonance between what is being said and what is being done. Our leaders say we want to transition to a green, renewable future, and in fact they are doing the exact opposite of what needs to be done to achieve it.
Words and action have a harmony, a congruency, too. My father drilled into me: “You are your word in action. If you do not do what you say, you become the boy who cried wolf. Your words become hollow and mean nothing.”
So if I was going to speak here as a songwriter, I knew I had to speak to the lack of harmony in the song currently being written in WA, and to this state’s role in the climate emergency.
Simply put: the lyrics and melody, the chords and rhythm, aren’t matching. They don’t work together or support each other the way they do when a song is working.
The lyrics
The state government and the gas industry are saying this:
Help transition to a renewable future? Challenge accepted.
Net zero by 2050? Challenge accepted.
Using science and technology to build better, safer futures.
Helping working-class families transition to greener industries and a greener future? Challenge accepted.
Sounds hopeful. Sounds like they know what they’re talking about. Sounds like they’re listening to the science.
But here is what I see them doing. These are the chords backing up those hopeful lyrics.
Chord 1: Woodside’s Burrup Hub
The extension and expansion of Woodside’s Burrup Hub, the North West Shelf gas facility, has been granted approval. The extension runs to 2070, twenty years past the 2050 net zero target. It will end up as Australia’s longest-operating and most polluting gas development in history, with four billion tonnes of emissions over its lifetime.1
If the Burrup Hub were a country, it would emit more carbon each year than Ireland and New Zealand combined: 88 million tonnes of CO₂ a year.
The emissions from the current facility are eroding Murujuga, home to the world’s oldest and largest collection of First Nations rock art, now recognised as a World Heritage site. Other countries put their far younger rock art behind glass panels for preservation. We poison ours.
Chord 2: Scott Reef and the Browse Basin
Woodside is proposing 50 oil rigs around this special reef, with 1.6 billion tonnes of carbon and greenhouse gas pollution over the life of the project.
Chord 3: Fracking the Kimberley
Picture a Texan oil field. If all went well, the best-case scenario for the state government and the Texas-based fracking company Bennett Resources would look like that: hundreds of wells, and thousands of kilometres of gas pipes heading to where? The Burrup Hub, baby. It’s a nightmare scenario for a fragile ecosystem.
And it’s also a fracker’s wet dream.
Chord 4: Alcoa and South32’s forest strip mining
Bauxite mining is now the leading cause of deforestation in the South West.
Our own state-owned Water Corporation stated in 2022 that bauxite mining operations represent the single most significant risk to water quality in the Perth metropolitan and South West drinking water catchments. In response to Alcoa’s draft Mining Management Program 2023–2027, Water Corporation said: “Probability of contamination of the reservoirs is considered certain.”2
Considered certain.
Don’t worry, the project has been given an exemption to keep operating!
All of these are the chords meant to go with those hopeful lyrics, and they are all ticking carbon bombs. This is not the rhythm I want to dance to. This is a rhythm I won’t be dancing to.
Does it add up?
But surely this makes excellent economic sense for the state, right?
Yeah… nah.
Jobs. Just 0.7% of the state’s workforce is employed in oil and gas extraction. For comparison, over 14% work in health care and social services.
Revenue. Vehicle registration delivers nearly three times more money to the WA Government than gas royalties do. Beer excise tax was greater than the combined tax payments of Woodside and Exxon. We’re getting more from beer, utes and student debt than we are from these corporations.3
As I said, I’m a songwriter, not an economist, but this just isn’t adding up, is it?
The fact is, we don’t need new gas. Our 15% domestic gas reservation policy allows the state to insulate itself against market volatility, keeping our bills and reserves stable. No gas shortages, no price hikes. No more new gas needed.
I think the initial melody on top is nice. It has a great ring to it and some great hooks: “Transition to a green future. Challenge accepted.” But even if we stopped expanding the gas industry today and were left with only what we already have, we’d still be behind schedule for our 2050 net zero targets. And what we’re seeing is that nothing is stopping. It’s expanding and accelerating.
The chords underneath the melody are completely out. Discordant. Dissonant. They’re two completely different songs.
The real threat
I don’t think humanity’s greatest threat is the destruction of the environment and ecology. It isn’t global warming or climate change, or AI, or war, or economic collapse. It’s the blatant capture of our governing bodies by the corporations that are driving all of those corrosive forces.
These same corporations then try to buy a social licence by purchasing advertising space across the chests and backs of our football teams and our kids’ lifesaving outfits, and by hanging banners across schools and arts festivals. It’s predatory, parasitic, creepy and, frankly, gross.
Meanwhile, the revolving door between government and industry is so blatant that we have politicians leaving office and rolling straight into high-paying jobs in the very industries they were just regulating.4 The inmates are running the asylum. We seem to be dealing with entities, and an economic rationale, that are fanatic in nature.
We have a moral, environmental, social and political crisis on our hands: a major, screeching dissonance with far-reaching and critical implications.
I’d be lying if I didn’t admit to often feeling overwhelmed, hopeless, frustrated, angry and dismayed. I look around and see such goodwill, such incredible intention, the brains trust in this room alone: the passion, intelligence, motivation and initiative, and an overwhelming amount of data and science to back it up. And then to see the government and industry response to it, the denial of the science, is maddening, and I get lost in that at times.
And then I need to get back to the song. Back to looking for harmony.
What works
What I have seen work time and again, the most effective method for making maximum change in the least amount of time, is non-violent direct action and civil disobedience. And I think we can all agree we’re out of time.
On the ground, we make a difference. Get busy. Get active. Get creative.
According to research out of Harvard University, analysing 323 political campaigns held between 1900 and 2006, no non-violent campaign that won the active support of 3.5% of the population has failed.5 Non-violent direct action and civil disobedience work.
We have successful campaigns in our history that are part of the folklore of our nation:
• Jabiluka
• The Gurindji Wave Hill Walk-Off and Vincent Lingiari: “From little things, big things grow”
• Eddie Mabo, fighting for land rights and opposing the idea of terra nullius
I’ve been very fortunate over the years to be part of some amazing, successful campaigns: the forest campaigns of the ‘90s, James Price Point, protecting the Great Australian Bight, and the South West Frack Off campaign. Sometimes it meant sitting on a shit bucket 110 metres up in one of the world’s largest tree sits, in the Styx Valley in lutruwita (Tasmania), playing my grandfather’s slide guitar. That forest is still under threat.
In order to succeed, all of the science, goodwill, innovation, experience and brains trust in this room is going to need a switched-on, tuned-in community around it to protect it. So now, more than ever, is the time. Tune in. Turn up. Turn on.
• See an event or rally protecting your right to protest and free speech? Attend.
• Find a representative who will fight for your best interests? Support them.
• See some of our elders baking cupcakes with cool messaging? Buy some.
• See an information night on fracking, or a fundraiser for a campaign? Go, go, go.
John closed his address by inviting the audience to join him that afternoon on the steps of Parliament House, where he and a big mob of people were standing once again to protect the Kimberley from fracking.
I’ll probably be playing next to a bin again. Still asking for change. Or maybe I’m demanding it now.
I believe that being active is one of the best ways to combat depression, anxiety and hopelessness. It’s the antidote to fear, loneliness, powerlessness and isolation.
Picture a room full of bright-eyed, determined individuals. It reminds me of a quote attributed to Margaret Mead:6
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.
I’m a firm believer that the biggest tech we have is each other. We have every chance to have real agency in our future. But the people have to will it. The establishment will never do it unless it is made to be congruent. There’s nothing wrong with a bit of agitation, and a little civil disobedience, to make a good song work.
When I think of the word agitation, I think of Frederick Douglass, one of the most important leaders of the African-American civil rights movement of the 19th century:
If there is no struggle, there is no progress. Those who profess to favor freedom, and yet depreciate agitation, are men who want crops without plowing up the ground. They want rain without thunder and lightning. They want the ocean without the awful roar of its many waters. This struggle may be a moral one; or it may be a physical one; or it may be both moral and physical; but it must be a struggle. Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.
Everyone has a note to play
There are many notes, instruments, voices and movements in an orchestra, a choir, a rock band, even a trio. We don’t all need to be frontline lock-on activists, but we all bring our own particular note to complete this symphony. Every member and every note is important to the whole.
We all have a part to sing. A rhythm to stomp. A chorus to wail.
We are being called, even forced, to co-write one of the greatest anthems of our times. It’s absolutely essential that we succeed.
I really want to hear this song with all the different parts working together. Congruently. In harmony. Sometimes I can hear it in my head: a song that is waiting to be sung. All of us singing and stomping together, in harmony, getting this job done.
Thank you.
Woodside estimates the North West Shelf extension to 2070 will emit up to 4.3 billion tonnes over its lifetime, and Greenpeace analysis puts it at 6.1 billion. The Climate Council puts the extension’s emissions at 88 million tonnes a year. Sources: Reuters via PGJ Online, Climate Council.
From the Water Corporation’s 2023 risk assessment of Alcoa’s 2023–2027 Mining Management Program. The WA Government approved the plan and granted Alcoa an exemption order in December 2023. Source: Boiling Cold (and re-published here on The Mining Monitor).
Figures from the Australia Institute: 0.7% of the WA workforce in oil and gas extraction; vehicle registration revenue of $1.319 billion against gas royalties of $522 million in the 2024–25 budget; and beer excise raising more than the combined company tax of Exxon, Woodside, Shell and Chevron in 2022. Sources: WA drivers pay more rego than gas companies pay in royalties, Gas in Western Australia.
Mark McGowan was Premier of WA from 2017 to 2023. An August 2024 ASX announcement of his appointment as chairman of Frontier Energy lists advisory roles with BHP. Source: ASX announcement. The revolving door was discussed in our “Extraction Without Borders” article.
Erica Chenoweth (Harvard Kennedy School) and Maria Stephan, Why Civil Resistance Works (2011). It is a descriptive finding about their dataset of 323 campaigns, not a guarantee of success. Source: summary of the 3.5% rule.
Widely attributed to Margaret Mead, but the original source is not firmly documented.